Having trouble finding an eyeliner that doesn't make your eyes feel itchy and irritated?

We know the struggle, which is why we've put together a list of the 5 best hypoallergenic eyeliners. These liners are perfect for those with sensitive eyes, and they come highly recommended by people who have actually tried them out. So whether you're in the market for a new liner or just curious about what's out there, read on for our top picks!

Not only are these eyeliners perfect for those with sensitive eyes, but they also come in a variety of colors and styles so you can find the perfect one for you. Plus, they're all affordable so you don't have to break the bank to get great quality.

How We Picked the Best Options

It's hard to find the best hypoallergenic eyeliner.

With so many different types of eyeliners on the market, it can be hard to determine which one is right for you. Not only do you have to worry about finding an eyeliner that doesn't cause irritation, but you also have to consider the color, style, and finish.

We've done the research for you and picked out the 5 best hypoallergenic eyeliners on the market. Whether you're looking for a liquid liner, gel liner, or pencil liner, we've got you covered.

Best Water Resistant and Long Wearing Eyeliner Pencil

Almay Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil 

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love This Product

Looking for a hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil that won't let you down? Meet the Almay eyeliner pencil which is water-resistant and long-wearing. This easy-to-use pencil eyeliner glides on smoothly, delivering rich pigmentation that lasts all day long - no smudging or smearing necessary.

It contains polymer, which is a substance that forms chains of molecules. This helps the product adhere better to the skin and makes it less likely to smudge or run.

Also, it contains mineral oil that helps absorb moisture. This is helpful because it prevents the liner from running or fading when it comes into contact with sweat or tears. Plus, it's safe for those with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

Important to Know

The Almay hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil offers a multitude of benefits, particularly when it comes to guaranteeing a long-lasting beautiful color that won't fade or smudge. This 16-hour formula is also oil-free, so you can be sure your liner won't run, smear, or rub off.

Plus, the added vitamin E nourishes and conditions the delicate skin around the eyes, leaving your peepers feeling healthy and looking great. Also, it can help to soothe and protect the delicate skin around the eyes.

Vitamin E is also an antioxidant, which can help to protect against free radical damage. Finally, it can help to improve the appearance of skin tone and texture.

Best Eyeliner Pencil With Zero Harsh Additives

BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love This Product

Introducing BaeBlu natural hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil – the perfect eye accessory for those with sensitive skin or allergic reactions to traditional cosmetics. This all-natural eyeliner pencil contains no harsh additives, so you can have the confidence in knowing that your look is safe and healthy, and worry-free.

This special formula glides on perfectly every time, giving you beautiful smudge-proof lines with ease.

Be daring and draw attention everywhere you go! So why hesitate? With BaeBlu natural hypoallergenic eyeliner pencil you can make every day a beauty day.

Important to Know

The BaeBlu natural eyeliner pencil is the most popular among most eyeliner pencil that offer unique benefits for those with sensitive eyes. Full of healthy, clean ingredients such as jojoba oil and castor oil that won't irritate your eyes.

Jojoba oil is a well-known moisturizer, helping to keep the area around the eyes hydrated and reducing the chances of irritation. Castor oil has many benefits as well including reducing inflammation, encouraging healing, and even stimulating hair growth - perfect for the delicate skin around the eye area!

With this great eyeliner pencil, you can always be sure that your eyes will be taken care of without sacrificing beautiful results.

Best Eyeliner That is Hypoallergenic and Fragrance-Free

Marcelle Velvet Gel Eyeliner 

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love This Product

Are you always on the hunt for a perfect eyeliner that glides on like velvet? Introducing Marcelle velvet gel eyeliner! This waterproof eyeliner is designed for easy application.

Feel confident knowing your eyes are lined with luxurious velvet and kept safe from irritation, as this gel eyeliner is hypoallergenic and fragrance-free.

Get ready to look glamorous all day with a long-lasting beautiful color that never smudges or transfers. Finish off any eye look quickly, easily, and precisely with Marcelle Velvet gel eyeliner.

Important to Know

The Marcelle velvet gel eyeliner is an exceptional product that provides long-lasting benefits. Its formula guarantees a 24-hour look without the need for touchups, meaning that your eye makeup will always look flawless.

Plus, its benefits are enhanced by the addition of synthetic wax and ferrocyanide, which helps the liner adhere well to your eyelid. If a smokey effect is desired, you can also blend the eyeliner after application for a more natural look.

Overall, this high-quality velvet gel eyeliner is both easy to apply and long-wearing - the perfect combination for any makeup routine.

Best Eye Liner Made With Aloe Leaf Extract

Pyt Beauty Liquid Eye Liner 

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love This Product

Get a defined cat-eye look with the Pyt beauty liquid eyeliner! Perfect for all beauty lovers, this luxurious eyeliner is exactly what makes classic eyeliner look easier than ever. Made with aloe leaf extract which leaves your skin feeling hydrated and smooth.

Aloe leaf extract can help to improve the overall health of your eyes. It can help to protect the eyes from UV radiation damage, reduce inflammation, and improve blood circulation. Get ready to stand out and make a lasting impact with the Pyt Beauty liquid eyeliner!

Important to Know

The Pyt beauty liquid eyeliner certainly benefits those looking for a vegan and cruelty-free eyeliner that is also Leaping Bunny Certified. It goes one step further to ensure your comfort and safety; made without harsh chemicals, it won't cause irritation or discomfort when being applied to the eyes.

Additionally - and this is an important plus point from other brands - it is carbon black and coal tar free despite its potent performance capabilities.

The jojoba esters in this eyeliner make it incredibly smooth to glide across the eyes and provide long-lasting stay-put power that is smudge-resistant, and won't cake or flake throughout the day.

Best Eyeliner With Flex Tip Applicator

Almay Intense Liquid Eyeliner 

Check Price on Amazon

Why We Love This Product

Almay intense liquid eyeliner gives you that mesmerizing, dramatic look you've been wanting, but with a flexible felt tip so you don't have to worry about it smudging or slipping! The ultra-thin tip applicator makes it easy to create any eye look—from subtle definition to bold and daring.

The flex tip applicator makes it easy to create thin or thick lines, depending on your preference. Also, the tip is more forgiving than a typical hard eyeliner pencil, so it's less likely to cause mistakes. Additionally, the soft tip makes it easier to apply liner close to your lash line without causing any irritation.

Important to Know

If you're looking for an eyeliner that will give your eyes a perfect pop of color, then the Almay intense liquid eyeliner is the ideal product for you.

With its unique inkwell bottle design and smooth formula, users can rest assured that their eyes look fabulous all day long without worrying about smears or smudges. Additionally, users with sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses can use this liner worry-free, as it has been ophthalmologist tested!

Try the Almay intense liquid eyeliner today and experience its precise control that yields precise lines easily--your eyes are sure to thank you!


It can be hard to find an eyeliner that doesn't cause a reaction for people with sensitive eyes.

If you've ever had a bad reaction to an eyeliner, then you know how important it is to find one that's hypoallergenic.

Our FAQs about hypoallergenic eyeliners will provide you with all the related information so you may make an informed decision about buying them.

What is the best hypoallergenic eyeliner for sensitive eyes?

Some general tips that may help include looking for an eyeliner that is hypoallergenic and fragrance-free and that is made from natural ingredients. Additionally, it's important to avoid eyeliners with harsh chemicals or metals (e.g., aluminum), as these can often cause skin irritation.

If you are unsure about a particular eyeliner, it's always best to test it out on a small patch of skin first to see if there is any reaction.

Some of the best eyeliners are Almay eyeliner, BaeBlu eyeliner, Pyt liquid eyeliner, and Honest Beauty liquid eyeliner.

Why is my eyeliner irritating my eyes?

It could be because the eyeliner is too harsh for your eyes and is causing them to dry out.

Another possibility is that you may be allergic to one of the ingredients in the eyeliner. If this is the case, you'll likely have other symptoms such as redness, swelling, or itching.

It's also possible that you're applying the eyeliner incorrectly and are getting it too close to your eyes. This can cause irritation and even infection if not cleaned properly.

What is the most hypoallergenic eye makeup?

There is no such thing as "hypoallergenic" eye makeup. However, there are certain types of makeup that are less likely to cause an allergic reaction. For example, cream-based eye shadows are typically less allergenic than powder-based shadows. Additionally, choose the makeup that is fragrance-free, since fragrance is a common allergen. Finally, avoid eye makeup that contains any type of metal (e.g., nickel, chromium) as these metals can also trigger an allergic reaction.

How do you know if you're allergic to eyeliner?

If you're allergic to eyeliner, you'll likely have some sort of reaction when you use it. This could be anything from redness and swelling around the eyes to a more serious allergic reaction that causes difficulty breathing and even anaphylactic shock.

If you think you might be allergic to eyeliner, it's best to speak with your doctor. They can help you determine if you're truly allergic and give you advice on how to safely use eyeliner if you are.

What happens if you're allergic to eyeliner?

If you're allergic to eyeliner, you may experience redness, swelling, itching, and/or burning around the eyes. You may also experience watery eyes or a runny nose if your allergies are severe enough. If this happens, it's important to discontinue the use of the product immediately and consult a doctor if necessary. 

What ingredients should I avoid with sensitive eyes?

If you have sensitive eyes, it's important to avoid any ingredients that may cause irritation or an allergic reaction. These include harsh chemicals such as parabens, sulfates, and phthalates; fragrances; and metals such as nickel or chromium. It's also important to check the ingredients list of any eyeliner you are about to buy.

Why are my eyes suddenly sensitive to makeup?

There could be a few reasons why your eyes are suddenly sensitive to makeup. For starters, over time the skin around our eyes becomes thinner and more delicate, so using harsh products or tugging at the skin while applying makeup can lead to inflammation and sensitivity. Additionally, as we age our tear production decreases which can leave the eyes more vulnerable to irritants.

How do you get rid of eye makeup allergies?

There are a few things you can do to get rid of eye makeup allergies. First, try using hypoallergenic makeup brands. Second, avoid using products that contain harsh chemicals or fragrances. Third, make sure to wash your hands and face before applying makeup. And finally, discontinue the use of any products that cause irritation or redness. If the symptoms persist, it's best to consult with an allergist.

Can eyeliner cause swollen eyelid?

It is possible for eyeliner to cause swollen eyelids, especially if it is applied too heavily or if the ingredients in the liner are not well-suited for your skin type. Heavy application of liner can lead to irritation and inflammation.

Is there makeup for people with allergies?

Yes. In fact, many cosmetics companies have "allergy-free" lines of products.

For people with allergies, it's important to read the labels of all products carefully to make sure that they are not containing any ingredients that you are allergic to. Also, it's a good idea to test out new products on a small area of your skin before using them all over your face.


If you are looking for an eyeliner that will not cause any irritation to your eyes, we recommend trying one of the five hypoallergenic eyeliners detailed in this post. We hope our review has helped you find the perfect product for your needs.