Tired of all the guesswork when it comes to picking out a brown eyeliner? We’ve got you covered! In this post, we’ll be reviewing five of the best brown eyeliner options available and discussing what makes each one unique. So whether you have round eyes, brown eyes, hooded eyes, almond-shaped eyes, or something else entirely, we’ve got a Brown eyeliner that will work for you!

Keep reading to find out more and pick up your favorite brown eyeliner today.

Our Process of Picking These Products

Brown eyeliner is a great option for everyday wear, but it can be hard to find the perfect one.

With so many brown eyeliners on the market, it can be hard to know which one is right for you. Do you want a matte finish? A metallic sheen? Something waterproof?

We've done the research for you and found the 5 best brown eyeliners on the market. Whether you're looking for something subtle or smoky, we've got you covered.

Best Smudge Proof and Smooth Brown Eyeliner

NYX Brown Eyeliner

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Looking for an eyeliner that will stay put all day long? Look no further than NYX Eyeliner. This smooth, smudge-proof liner goes on effortlessly and provides long-lasting wear.

This eyeliner is made with a waterproof or smudge-proof formula. This eyeliner will stay in place even if it gets wet. Another reason is that the eyeliner has been specifically designed to glide on easily and not tug at the skin. This eyeliner uses silicone oil as an ingredient to help them glide smoothly, which can also help make it smudge-proof.

Whether you’re creating a natural look or going for a bolder style, this eyeliner will help you achieve the perfect results.

Need-To-Know Things

NYX is a certified PETA product. This means that the company does not test its products on animals. The company is also registered with the Vegan Society, which requires that all products be free of animal-derived ingredients and by-products.

NYX's matte finish goes on smoothly and evenly, providing excellent coverage and color payoff. So, if you're looking for quality eyeliner that won't let you down, look no further than NYX!

Best Brown Eyeliner With Hyper Easy Brush Tip

Maybelline Brown Eyeliner

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Looking for an easy-to-use eyeliner that will give you the perfect winged look? Maybelline Eyeliner is your go-to product! The Hyper easy brush tip allows for precise application, so you can create any look you want - from a natural day look to a smoky eye for the evening.

The hyper-easy tip makes it much easier to create a precise line. This is especially helpful for those who are new to applying eyeliner or who have difficulty making a straight line. Second, the brush applicator helps to evenly distribute the product along the lashline, which gives your eyes a more natural look.

Need-To-Know Things

Looking for an eyeliner that will give you the perfect cat eye? Look no further than Maybelline Eyeliner has a revolutionary flex tip brush and custom hexagonal grip that give you optimal control and easy, stable application.

Plus, the satin finish will make your eyes pop! Whether you’re a beginner or a pro, Maybelline Eyeliner is the perfect choice for creating stunning eye looks.

Best Brown Eyeliner With Metallic Finish

Covergirl Brown Eyeliner

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Looking for an eyeliner that will give your eyes a little extra pop? Then you need Covergirl's Metallic eyeliner! This richly pigmented eyeliner goes on smoothly and evenly and dries to a beautiful metallic finish that will make your eyes stand out.

The metallic finish makes eyes look brighter and more awake. It can also help to make the eyes look bigger since it brings attention to the upper lid.

Whether you're looking to create a subtle cat eye or a bold and dramatic look, this eyeliner is perfect for achieving any style. So don't wait any longer, give your eyes the attention they deserve with Covergirl's Metallic eyeliner!

Need-To-Know Things

Covergirl's versatile eye pencil is specially designed to help you create your perfect eyeliner look. The pencil's self-sharpening tip means that you'll always have a sharp point, and the easy-to-use design makes it easy to create a variety of looks.

Plus, Covergirl's eyeliner is Leaping Bunny Certified by Cruelty-Free International, so you can be sure that it has not been tested on animals. Whether you're looking for a natural look or a smokey eye, Covergirl's versatile eye pencil can help you achieve your desired look.

Best Brown Eyeliner With Quick Drying Formula

L'Oreal Paris Brown Eyeliner

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Looking for a quick and easy way to achieve the perfect eyeliner look? L'Oreal Paris has your covered with their Quick Dry Eyeliner. This liner comes with a quick dry formula that makes it easy to apply and achieve a flawless look.

The quick-drying formula of eyeliner works because it contains an alcohol-based solvent. This solvent evaporates quickly, which causes the liner to dry quickly.

So go ahead and rock that smoky eye look or go for a more dramatic cat eye - with L'Oreal Paris Eyeliner, the possibilities are endless!

Need-To-Know Things

L'Oreal Paris Eyeliner is a type of eyeliner that allows you to create a sleek and sophisticated look. The eyeliner pen has a 0.4-millimeter tip that allows you to apply it to your eyelids.

The L'Oreal Paris Eyeliner is also waterproof and long-wearing, so you can be confident that your makeup will last all day long. If you are looking for an eyeliner that will give you a polished and professional look, then the L'Oreal Paris Eyeliner is the perfect choice for you.

Best Brown Eyeliner With Precise Tip

Stila Brown Eyeliner

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love About It

Looking for an eyeliner that will give you the perfect winged look? Stila Eyeliner is your go-to product! The Precise tip allows for easy application, so you'll never have to worry about uneven lines or mistakes.

The Precise tip of eyeliner makes it easy to create a thin, precise line. This is especially helpful if you want to create a winged eyeliner look. It makes it easy to get into the corners of your eyes. This is important because liner in the corners can make your eyes look rounder and more awake.

So whether you're hitting the town for a night out or attending a daytime event, this eyeliner will have you looking your best.

Need-To-Know Things

Stila Eyeliner is a versatile tool that can help you create a variety of looks. For a bold, dramatic look, angle the pen and apply with slightly more pressure. You can also build up the intensity of the color by applying additional layers.

For best performance, store the pen horizontally. This will help to prevent the ink from drying out and clumping. With a little practice, you'll be able to create any type of look you want with Stila Eyeliner.


You want to wear brown eyeliner, but you're not sure which shade will work best for your skin tone.

There are a lot of different shades of brown eyeliner available on the market, and it can be hard to figure out which one is right for you.

We've put together a list of FAQs about the different shades of brown eyeliner to help make your decision easier.

What is the best brown eyeliner?

There are a few things to look for when choosing brown eyeliner. The first is that it should be easy to apply and blend. Second, the color should be rich and opaque, so that it can create a strong contrast against your skin. Finally, it's important to find eyeliner that will last all day without smudging or fading.

Some of the best eyeliners are Stila eyeliner, L'Oreal Paris eyeliner, Black or Brown eyeliner, Brown eyeliner pencil, and Brown liquid eyeliner.

Who should wear brown eyeliner?

Brown eyeliner can be worn by anyone depending on their skin tone and what look they're going for.

Those with fairer skin tones should opt for light brown or beige eyeliners, while those with darker skin tones can wear darker brown shades. Dark Brown eyeliner can also be blended with other colors to create different looks, so it's a versatile option that anyone can wear.

Which eyeliner is best, brown or black?

Brown eyeliner is best for two reasons. First, brown eyeliner is less harsh than black eyeliner and can be used to create a softer look. Second, brown eyeliner can be used to enhance the natural color of your eyes, while black eyeliner can often make your eyes look too dramatic.

If you are new to using eyeliner, I would recommend starting with brown because it is easier to use and less likely to cause any mistakes. Once you get more comfortable using eyeliner, then you can try experimenting with black liner.

What eyeliner makes you look younger?

If you want to look younger, choosing a color for your upper eyelid other than black is essential. Aim for something “softer” rather than black. Also, it's important to find a product that sticks within the natural colors of our environment- like gray, brown, or navy blue.

Does brown eyeliner look more natural?

It depends on your skin tone. For people with cool undertones, brown eyeliner will look more natural because it will be closer to the color of their eyes. 

For people with warm undertones, brown eyeliner may not look as natural because it will be a bit darker than their eyes. In that case, black eyeliner may be a better option.

Does brown eyeliner make your eyes look bigger?

Yes, brown eyeliner can make your eyes look bigger by defining the lash line and making the whites of your eyes look brighter. It's a classic trick used by makeup artists to make eyes look more awake and bigger. 

The easiest way to do this is to start at the inner corner of your eye and work your way outwards. You can also use a light brown or beige liner for a more natural look.

Is it better to wear eyeliner on top or bottom?

It Depends. Some people prefer to wear eyeliner on the top lid and some people prefer to wear it on the bottom lid. 

It really depends on your eyes and what look you are going for. Some people think that wearing eyeliner on the bottom lid makes their eyes look larger, while others think that it makes them look tired. Experiment with different looks and see what you like the best!

How should a 40-year-old wear eyeliner?

A 40-year-old should wear eyeliner in a way that accentuates her eyes without looking too youthful or older than she is.

For women over 40, the liner should be applied subtly and in thin lines rather than thick, dramatic strokes. You can line the top of your lashes for definition, but avoid drawing a line all the way around your eye - this will only make you look much younger. Try using a light brown eyeliner or gray color for a natural look.

Where should you not apply eyeliner?

There are a few general guidelines to follow when applying eyeliner. For example, you should avoid drawing a line too close to the inner corner of your eye, as this can make your eyes look smaller. 

You should also avoid lining the inner rims of your eyes, as this can cause irritation and make your eyes look red and tired. Finally, you should avoid extending your eyeliner too far out past the outer corner of your eye, as this can make your eyes look droopy.

How do you make your eyes look bigger as you get older?

The fatty tissues around the eyes tend to thin as you get older, which can make your eyes look smaller. You can make your eyes look bigger by using an eye cream or serum that plumps up the skin around your eyes and makes them look more awake.

Another way to make your eyes look bigger is to use a light-reflecting concealer under your eyes. This will help to brighten up the area and make your eyes appear larger. Be sure not to use too much concealer, or it will end up looking cakey.

Final Thoughts

All of these brown eyeliners are great options for a natural look. If you’re looking for an everyday eyeliner that will make your eyes pop without being too dramatic, any of these five would work well.

However, if you have specific needs or preferences, one option may be better suited to you than the others. Hopefully, our reviews have helped you narrow down the search and find the perfect brown liner for your needs.